Powered by GDPR plugin

Privacy Overview

My website uses cookies to gather information about how visitors use my website to help me improve its performance, and secondly, to improve the visitor experience when using the website by delivering pages more quickly or remembering user settings.

Additionally, videos on the website may use cookies created by third-party providers such as Flash or YouTube.

The information I collect is anonymous – it cannot be used to identify you personally.

You can adjust all of your cookie settings by navigating the tabs on the left hand side.

Strictly Necessary Cookies

Strictly Necessary Cookie should be enabled at all times so that we can save your preferences for cookie settings.

If you disable this cookie, we will not be able to save your preferences. This means that every time you visit this website you will need to enable or disable cookies again.

  •  01241 873 058
  •  graeme.dey.msp@parliament.scot
Graeme Dey
  •   News  
    •   Latest News
    •   Motions
    •   Speeches
  •   About  
    •   About – Graeme Dey MSP
    •   Carer Positive
    •   Cookies
    •   Data Protection GDPR
  •   Surgeries  
    •   Surgery Times
    •   Surgery Locations
  •   Contact  
    •   Contact Graeme
  •   News  
    •   Latest News
    •   Motions
    •   Speeches
  •   About  
    •   About – Graeme Dey MSP
    •   Carer Positive
    •   Cookies
    •   Data Protection GDPR
  •   Surgeries  
    •   Surgery Times
    •   Surgery Locations
  •   Contact  
    •   Contact Graeme

Migration Debate

Migration Debate

Graeme yesterday spoke in a debate on migration. He took the opportunity to highlight the issue of the seasonal migrant workforce which the soft fruit sector in Angus needs access to.

<div style=”width:auto”><div style=”position:relative;height:0;padding-bottom:56.25%;”><iframe src=”https://www.scottishparliament.tv/meeting/debate-scotlands-population-needs-and-migration-policy-february-22-2018/embed?clip_start=15:39:48&clip_end=15:44:14″ style=”position:absolute;top:0;left:0;width:100%;height:100%;border:0″ frameborder=”no” scrolling=”no” allowfullscreen mozAllowFullscreen webkitallowfullscreen></iframe></div></div>

 

This feels a wee bit like groundhog day. We are the best part of two years on from the fateful Brexit vote, and still we have no resolution on what migration will look like after we leave the EU. I find myself rising in the chamber yet again to highlight its implications for a key economic contributor in my constituency—the soft fruit sector.

In the time since I first raised the matter back in late June 2016, little has changed—apart, that is, from the growing evidence of the negative impact that Brexit and the accompanying uncertainties are having. Despite lobbying by the sector and Scottish Government support for its efforts to have Westminster recognise its need to access a seasonal migrant workforce, we are no further forward. Michael Gove may have promised Scots fruit farmers news on a way forward by the end of next month, but then he went in front of the English NFU and admitted that the decision is outwith his control.

Farms in my constituency are utterly dependent on people from other countries coming to pick the fruit that they grow—many of them come back year after year. However, the anti-immigration rhetoric that characterised the Brexit debate, coupled with the falling value of the pound, has already led regular returners either to opt for pastures new or to draw up plans for a future away from Scotland.

As is noted in the Scottish Government’s discussion paper that was published before the February recess, many businesses have expressed concerns about the impact that is already being felt—concerns that are rightly shared by the SNP Government. The evidence of the impacts goes beyond anecdotal evidence. As I laid out in a debate in November last year, the co-operative organisation Angus Growers, which is based largely in my constituency, needs 4,100 workers annually. Last year, 347 seasonal employees either did not arrive or left early. As a direct consequence, the farms took a combined £660,000 hit. Angus Growers and the wider sector are bracing themselves. The 2018 season is fast approaching, and next month is when the EU workforce returns. Last year set a trend, and no one seriously expects to see it being reversed.

I will share some bang-up-to-date supporting evidence from the major farm in the Angus Growers collective. On that farm in 2016, 296 of the workforce out in the field were returners from the previous year. In 2017, that number dropped to 267. The total that is confirmed for the coming year stands at 212, which represents a drop of almost 19 per cent in just 12 months. That simply cannot be allowed to go unchecked—not for Angus, not for Scotland and not, indeed, for the rest of the UK.

A recent report in The Guardian revealed that a soft fruit farmer in Herefordshire is to move some of his company’s raspberry and blueberry growing to China, which will lead to 200 seasonal jobs being lost. Citing the lack of clarity from the Prime Minister on the UK Government’s immigration policy, Angus Davison said:

“We are already out of time”.

Mr Davison has written to Theresa May, saying that

“Unless a seasonal workers scheme is put in place, you must expect to see the steep decline of this significant rural employer and source of food.”

Do we want to have to import from China food that can readily be grown on these islands, just because the UK Government is unwilling to recognise the needs of an industry? Is that to be one of the achievements of Brexit?

Of course, migration concerns are not restricted to agriculture and seasonal workers. The Scottish Government’s analysis paper estimates that Scotland’s gross domestic product will decrease by 4.5 per cent by 2040 if migration levels are reduced to the UK Government’s target levels. That is equivalent to a fall of almost £5 billion in GDP. Across the whole UK, the impact would be smaller—a 3.7 per cent reduction. If the UK Government were to reduce net migration to the tens of thousands, as some people have suggested, Scotland’s GDP would fall by 9.3 per cent, compared with 7.6 per cent for the UK.

I welcome the fact that the Scottish Government has developed proposals and a bespoke solution for Scotland in order to seek to address the matter. That is a sensible and necessary move, given the inertia at UK level. There is an indisputable need to plan for the UK Government failing to come up with a sensible UK-wide migration policy, which looks increasingly likely. As MSPs, we need to come together and pursue what is in Scotland’s best interests. Is not that what we were all elected to do?

  • Posted on 23rd February 2018
  • By Marco Florence
  • In
  • Previous Next

Post Tags


About The Author

Marco Florence
Office Manager

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Yorkshire Building Society CarnoustieYorkshire Building Society Carnoustie
£50M SCOTTISH GOVERNMENT SUPPORT FOR GP PRACTICES£50M SCOTTISH GOVERNMENT SUPPORT FOR GP PRACTICES
MSP BACKS CALL FOR BREXIT COMPENSATION FOR FARMERSMSP BACKS CALL FOR BREXIT COMPENSATION FOR FARMERS
UK GOVERNMENT FORCED TO ADMIT UNIVERSAL CREDIT CAUSED FOODBANK DEMAND  UK GOVERNMENT FORCED TO ADMIT UNIVERSAL CREDIT CAUSED FOODBANK DEMAND  
No Deal Brexit “Catastrophic” for Scotland’s Farmers and CroftersNo Deal Brexit “Catastrophic” for Scotland’s Farmers and Crofters
Universal Credit Support SessionsUniversal Credit Support Sessions
Holyrood Committee Calls for Urgent Welfare ReformHolyrood Committee Calls for Urgent Welfare Reform
Support for Local Charities and Community GroupsSupport for Local Charities and Community Groups
Budget Gets Holyrood Backing With Boost For Local ServicesBudget Gets Holyrood Backing With Boost For Local Services
MSP Welcomes Post Office Announcement for ArbroathMSP Welcomes Post Office Announcement for Arbroath
Audiology Service-MonifiethAudiology Service-Monifieth
SNP TAX PLANS LEAVES PUBLIC SECTOR WORKERS BETTER OFF THAN UK COUNTERPARTSSNP TAX PLANS LEAVES PUBLIC SECTOR WORKERS BETTER OFF THAN UK COUNTERPARTS
SNP PLANS TO INVEST £500 MILLION IN HISTORIC CHILDCARESNP PLANS TO INVEST £500 MILLION IN HISTORIC CHILDCARE
£10.5M FUNDING BOOST FOR ANGUS COUNCIL£10.5M FUNDING BOOST FOR ANGUS COUNCIL
Best Start Grant to Help YoungstersBest Start Grant to Help Youngsters
Unemployment Below 100,000 for the First Time EverUnemployment Below 100,000 for the First Time Ever
FUNDING BOOST WILL SEE ADDITONAL NURSES AND COUNSELLORS IN ANGUS SOUTH SCHOOLSFUNDING BOOST WILL SEE ADDITONAL NURSES AND COUNSELLORS IN ANGUS SOUTH SCHOOLS
MSP MEETS SCOTRAIL ALLIANCE SENIOR MANAGEMENTMSP MEETS SCOTRAIL ALLIANCE SENIOR MANAGEMENT
PM SCRAPS SETTLED STATUS FEE FOR EU CITIZENS AFTER SNP CAMPAIGNPM SCRAPS SETTLED STATUS FEE FOR EU CITIZENS AFTER SNP CAMPAIGN
SNP MSP WELCOMES FUNDING TO TACKLE ATTAINMENT GAP IN ANGUS SOUTHSNP MSP WELCOMES FUNDING TO TACKLE ATTAINMENT GAP IN ANGUS SOUTH
Carer Positive

c[p

Arbroath Office
This Website

There is no public cost as a result of the creation and maintenance of this site. All costs are personally borne by Graeme Dey.

The Living Wage
Living Wage
Graeme Dey
Theme By WordPress Eden

We are using cookies to give you the best experience on our website.

You can find out more about which cookies we are using or switch them off in settings.