Close Menu
Graeme DeyGraeme Dey
  • News
    • Angus South
    • Holyrood
    • Westminster
    • Education
  • About
    • Graeme Dey MSP
    • GDPR
      • Privacy Policy
      • Child Data Protection
      • Cookies
  • Surgeries
  • Issues
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Housing
    • Law & Order
    • Social Security
    • Transport
    • Devolved and Reserved Powers
  • Gallery
    • 2021 –
      • 2024
      • 2023
      • 2022
      • 2021
    • 2016 – 2020
      • 2020
      • 2019
      • 2018
      • 2017
      • 2016
    • 2011 – 2015
      • 2015
      • 2014
      • 2013
      • 2012
      • 2011
  • Videos
    • Members’ Business
    • Questions
      • First Minister’s Questions
      • General Questions
      • Portfolio Questions
      • Topical Questions
  • Contact
    • Contact Graeme
    • Generic Consent Form
    • NHS Consent Form
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube
Wednesday, May 14
Graeme DeyGraeme Dey
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube
  • News
    1. Angus South
    2. Holyrood
    3. Westminster
    4. Education
    5. View All

    Graeme’s Column

    18th April 2025

    14 Years of free prescriptions under the SNP Government

    2nd April 2025

    Pension Age Disability Payment opens in Angus

    24th March 2025

    Graeme’s Column

    21st March 2025

    One Year Until Scottish Parliament Election

    9th May 2025

    Labour Will Never Scrap 2-Child Cap

    30th April 2025

    Commitment to Safeguarding Democracy

    25th April 2025

    Rent Control Consultation Published

    23rd April 2025

    Labour immigration policy threatens Scotland’s NHS

    13th May 2025

    Minister condemns ā€˜devastating’ UK migration proposals

    12th May 2025

    Delay RTS Shutdown or Compensate Scots

    9th May 2025

    Grangemouth Stops Refining Oil

    30th April 2025

    Education Secretary visits University of Dundee

    15th April 2025

    Improving outdoor play

    24th March 2025

    Widening Access to University Education

    20th March 2025

    £4,900+ a Year for Student Carers

    20th March 2025

    Call for more foster carers

    13th May 2025

    Graeme’s Column

    13th May 2025

    Labour immigration policy threatens Scotland’s NHS

    13th May 2025

    Minister condemns ā€˜devastating’ UK migration proposals

    12th May 2025
  • About
    • Graeme Dey MSP
    • GDPR
      • Privacy Policy
      • Child Data Protection
      • Cookies
  • Surgeries
  • Issues
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Housing
    • Law & Order
    • Social Security
    • Transport
    • Devolved and Reserved Powers
  • Gallery
    • 2021 –
      • 2024
      • 2023
      • 2022
      • 2021
    • 2016 – 2020
      • 2020
      • 2019
      • 2018
      • 2017
      • 2016
    • 2011 – 2015
      • 2015
      • 2014
      • 2013
      • 2012
      • 2011
  • Videos
    • Members’ Business
    • Questions
      • First Minister’s Questions
      • General Questions
      • Portfolio Questions
      • Topical Questions
  • Contact
    • Contact Graeme
    • Generic Consent Form
    • NHS Consent Form
Graeme DeyGraeme Dey
You are at:Home»Holyrood»Scotland can look to Ireland for the opportunities independence brings
The Wallace Monument

Scotland can look to Ireland for the opportunities independence brings

GraemeBy Graeme9th October 20242 Views3 Mins Read Holyrood
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Reddit WhatsApp

Increased tax credits, greater help for families, support on energy prices, tax cuts, mortgage relief and more educational and law enforcement staff.

Unfortunately, this is not remotely what is being discussed in Westminster.

This is the latest budget from the Republic of Ireland, a country that has defied expectations, and is now a wealthy, happy, independent nation, at the heart of both Europe and the United Nations.

Independence has unleashed Ireland’s potential, with the country recently enjoying a budget surplus.

The latest budget includes one-off support payments for the cost-of-living, VAT cuts, an extension of free public transport and cuts in costs for students.

In contrast, Scotland is stuck with Labour and Tory parties at Westminster debating over how big a cut to Scotland’s ambition – and budget – should be made.

Taxation and Revenue

The UK’s withered tax system rewards the ultra-rich and persecutes hard-working voters. It has seen few major changes since Margaret Thatcher’s crusade to turn the UK from a compassionate society to one driven by competition, individualism and self-interest.

Even in 13 years of power, Blair and Brown failed to make the tax system properly progressive. And Sir Keir Starmer’s new Labour government offers no alternative, recently digging in its heels on a fresh round of austerity, ditching winter fuel payments while keeping the brutal two-child benefit cap.

With full powers over tax, the Scottish Parliament would not need Westminster’s consent to introduce new revenue-raising ideas currently ignored by Westminster.

Scotland would be able to make our tax system fairer and more sustainable, ditching the Tories’ economic orthodoxy, that is harming economic growth, and to which Labour are now fully subscribed.

With full tax powers, Scotland would be able to pursue progressive income tax policies while ensuring competitive business and corporate taxes that attract investment and jobs, which Ireland has pioneered so successfully.

I don’t think I have ever seen a budget in which there are only winners. Quite the impressive list from Dublin today: what a contrast to the upcoming UK scenario. pic.twitter.com/PG3BNsofFr

— Duncan Morrow (@duncan_morrow) October 1, 2024

Labour’s cuts are punishing Scotland

The Scotland of today is unrecognisable from the Scotland Labour left to be fixed in 2007.

Not only do we now have the most GPs per head, the best paid nurses in the UK, more affordable housing, and the only NHS not to have ground to a halt because of pay disputes.

We also have a country that is more in line with the European neighbours we admire and respect.

Free prescriptions, free tuition, free personal care. A nationalised rail service. Public infrastructure projects like the Queensferry Crossing delivered on time and under budget. A social security system that puts people first, and the game-changing Scottish Child Payment.

All this is in danger, thanks to Labour. Spending plans in Westminster have forced us here in Scotland to make difficult decisions.

Anas Sarwar and Scottish Labour are no different to their colleagues in Westminster. They’ve openly talked of bringing back tuition fees and would gladly take a sledgehammer to the Scotland we have built together over the last 17 years.

Ireland is sitting on a surplus of €24bn.

UK is sitting on a black hole of £22bn.

Just saying. https://t.co/26TiICBzsZ

— Stephen Flynn MP (@StephenFlynnSNP) September 27, 2024

Imagine our potential with independence

If we have achieved this much during 17 years, restrained by Westminster’s devolution rules and the lack of borrowing and tax powers, imagine what Scotland could do with the full powers of independence.

Like our neighbours in Ireland, we could truly build that better path that the Westminster politicians will tell you doesn’t exist. The one they’ll tell you only leads to ruin.

Well this week, it’s Ireland’s turn to prove them wrong.

energy Independence Ireland mortgage relief Scotland tax credits tax cuts
Previous ArticleMSPs Vote for Action on Winter Fuel Payment
Next Article Improved Support for Crime Victims
Graeme

Member of the Scottish Parliament for Angus South Constituency. Minister for Higher and Further Education; and Minister for Veterans.

Related Posts

One Year Until Scottish Parliament Election

9th May 2025

Grangemouth Stops Refining Oil

30th April 2025

Labour Will Never Scrap 2-Child Cap

30th April 2025
latest news

Call for more foster carers

Graeme’s Column

Labour immigration policy threatens Scotland’s NHS

Minister condemns ā€˜devastating’ UK migration proposals

About
About

Graeme Dey is the the Member of the Scottish Parliament for Angus South Constituency.

Having worked for The Courier newspaper for 26 years, Graeme was elected to Holyrood in 2011.

In March 2023, Graeme was chosen by First Minister Humza Yousaf to be Minister for Higher and Further Education; and Minister for Veterans.

Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube
Latest Posts

Call for more foster carers

Graeme’s Column

Labour immigration policy threatens Scotland’s NHS

Minister condemns ā€˜devastating’ UK migration proposals

Flickr Photos
Transport Police
RM Condor Parliament 2
D&A College (Apprenticeship Week) 6
Deaf Hub 3
DofE3
Humza and Graeme close up pro
Humza Graeme Sign
Independence Convention
July7 Surgery 2]
CWA Parl 3
20230712_104835
20230712_110433
Banking Hub 1
SSERC
Ayrshire College
Poverty Alliance
© 2025 Graeme Dey MSP. No parliamentary funds have been used to create and maintain this website. Promoted by G. Dey, 282 High St, DD11 1JF.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.