Close Menu
Graeme DeyGraeme Dey
  • News
    • Angus South
    • Holyrood
    • Westminster
    • Education
  • About
    • Graeme Dey MSP
    • GDPR
      • Privacy Policy
      • Child Data Protection
      • Cookies
  • Surgeries
  • Issues
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Housing
    • Law & Order
    • Social Security
    • Transport
    • Devolved and Reserved Powers
  • Gallery
    • 2021 –
      • 2024
      • 2023
      • 2022
      • 2021
    • 2016 – 2020
      • 2020
      • 2019
      • 2018
      • 2017
      • 2016
    • 2011 – 2015
      • 2015
      • 2014
      • 2013
      • 2012
      • 2011
  • Videos
    • Members’ Business
    • Questions
      • First Minister’s Questions
      • General Questions
      • Portfolio Questions
      • Topical Questions
  • Contact
    • Contact Graeme
    • Generic Consent Form
    • NHS Consent Form
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube
Friday, June 20
Graeme DeyGraeme Dey
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube
  • News
    1. Angus South
    2. Holyrood
    3. Westminster
    4. Education
    5. View All

    Expanding Access to Childcare

    13th June 2025

    Welcoming the funding boost for Appetite for Angus, led by Angus Farmers Market

    9th June 2025

    Supporting Small Food & Drink Businesses

    4th June 2025

    Funding for Angus Climate Action Hub

    30th May 2025

    Securing Grangemouth’s Just Transition

    18th June 2025

    More Support for Care-Experienced Youth

    18th June 2025

    Scrapping 2-Child Limit to Fight Child Poverty

    17th June 2025

    Inward Investment Success

    17th June 2025

    Spending Review presents challenges

    12th June 2025

    Call for National Mission on Living Standards

    23rd May 2025

    Labour immigration policy threatens Scotland’s NHS

    13th May 2025

    Minister condemns ‘devastating’ UK migration proposals

    12th May 2025

    Scottish Languages Bill Passed

    18th June 2025

    Rise in School Leavers in Positive Destinations

    17th June 2025

    Building positive relationships in schools

    17th June 2025

    Boosting university spin-outs

    16th June 2025

    Securing Grangemouth’s Just Transition

    18th June 2025

    More Support for Care-Experienced Youth

    18th June 2025

    Scottish Languages Bill Passed

    18th June 2025

    Scrapping 2-Child Limit to Fight Child Poverty

    17th June 2025
  • About
    • Graeme Dey MSP
    • GDPR
      • Privacy Policy
      • Child Data Protection
      • Cookies
  • Surgeries
  • Issues
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Health
    • Housing
    • Law & Order
    • Social Security
    • Transport
    • Devolved and Reserved Powers
  • Gallery
    • 2021 –
      • 2024
      • 2023
      • 2022
      • 2021
    • 2016 – 2020
      • 2020
      • 2019
      • 2018
      • 2017
      • 2016
    • 2011 – 2015
      • 2015
      • 2014
      • 2013
      • 2012
      • 2011
  • Videos
    • Members’ Business
    • Questions
      • First Minister’s Questions
      • General Questions
      • Portfolio Questions
      • Topical Questions
  • Contact
    • Contact Graeme
    • Generic Consent Form
    • NHS Consent Form
Graeme DeyGraeme Dey
You are at:Home»News»We Must Not Accept Westminster Sovereignty As a Given

We Must Not Accept Westminster Sovereignty As a Given

LucieBy Lucie13th December 20225 Views5 Mins Read News
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Reddit WhatsApp

The big events of Scottish politics used to be Westminster by-elections.

Prior to the establishment of the Scottish Parliament, these gave the opportunity for Scotland to bring home – if only for three or so weeks – the type of political debates that nearly always took place elsewhere.

The most intense spectacle started with the second Govan by-election in November 1988 and continued through another six until Paisley South in 1997, which was the last before Holyrood was vested.

After 1999, they were of much less significance, as the focus of Scottish politics moved to the normal epicentre of such things.

A domestic parliament was established – albeit one that is still without all the powers needed to address Scotland’s needs and without the ability to apply all our resources to that task as well.

Those powers still lie at Westminster, and those resources are still being misused there. Consequently, it would be wrong to take our eye off that particular ball just yet.

Having a strong campaigning presence south of the Border is vital.

Change is the only constant in politics, no matter how difficult it can be for individuals.

Of course, the hard reality is that the core of Scotland’s constitutional problem lies amongst those green and red benches by the Thames because of their absolute adherence to the daft doctrine of Westminster sovereignty.

https://twitter.com/YesScot/status/1600881125177819136?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw%7Ctwcamp%5Etweetembed%7Ctwterm%5E1600881125177819136%7Ctwgr%5E38733326561e615d3d2c936f87208157c4d7be29%7Ctwcon%5Es1_&ref_url=http%3A%2F%2Fgraemedey.info%2Fnew%2Fwe-must-not-accept-westminster-sovereignty-as-a-given%2F

Jean-Jacques Rousseau pointed out that, even in his time, the people of England were only free when choosing their MPs.

That was, as Elliot Bulmer has commented, because, by the act of election, the power that they possessed went out of their hands and into the institution of Parliament which reigned supreme, using the name of the monarch as the fig leaf.

Westminster sovereignty asserts that no power is or can be greater than that exercised by Parliament via the government of the day and this power cannot be bound, even by predecessor governments.

Devolution was a delicate dance around that flawed doctrine.

It was devised in what now seems another political age in which ambiguity and compromise allowed the transfer of powers – albeit on Westminster terms – to other institutions, which included not just the devolved parliaments, but also those of the European Union.

Westminster sovereignty was not altered by such things, but those who devised them hoped that no one would really notice.

If the Scots or Welsh pushed the matter too far, then the law could be used to put them back in their box. Because Westminster sovereignty meant that it would always be the judge and jury, using legislation it itself had devised.

But, as with so many things, the moment of truth came with Brexit.

For Brexiteers – who now run UK politics – restoring what they saw as wrongfully eroded Westminster sovereignty was at the heart of their project, yet what would be the point of taking power back from Brussels if it was still ebbing away to Edinburgh or Cardiff?

Thus, Brexit was as much an anti-devolution construct as an insular backwards-looking anti-European one and is increasingly dangerous in that regard, as the current passage of the Retained EU Law Bill shows.

That is all summed up in those appalling words of the Secretary of State for Scotland to Deidre Brock some weeks ago – “suck it up”.

Alister Jack defended saying 'suck it up' to Deidre Brock after she raised concerns about the management of Levelling Up fundinghttps://t.co/vI0GA8qR8I

— The National (@ScotNational) June 23, 2022

That is what Westminster sovereignty actually means today – just suck up whatever Westminster says and does because you have no right to oppose it, and if you try, we can – and will – beat you every time.

Westminster finds that just fine because Westminster sovereignty is not just the fixed belief which underpins the Tory’s patronising, and offensive approach to Scotland – demonstrated again this week by the lazy and arrogant Penny Mordaunt who seems to think that she can teach others about government despite her and her colleagues’ woefully poor track record – but is also the foundation stone of those supposedly “new” proposals from Gordon Brown and Keir Starmer.

These already weak ideas could only mean something, no matter how little, if they were framed around an acceptance that Westminster sovereignty was an out-of-date and out-of-time concept that was going to be overturned.

In other words, if the UK under any Labour government was aiming to be a modern country with a modern, person-centred, written constitution. Which it isn’t.

So, without accepting that the notion of Westminster sovereignty is done and that popular sovereignty – power lying always with the people, which is the Scottish way – should replace it, then nothing that is promised by any Westminster party or politician can deliver us the right to make our own decisions in all the areas that count.

And especially not in a way that ensures accountability to our own citizens. Not to a parliament and government we did not elect.

https://twitter.com/YesScot/status/1596200270714744833?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw%7Ctwcamp%5Etweetembed%7Ctwterm%5E1596200270714744833%7Ctwgr%5E38733326561e615d3d2c936f87208157c4d7be29%7Ctwcon%5Es1_&ref_url=http%3A%2F%2Fgraemedey.info%2Fnew%2Fwe-must-not-accept-westminster-sovereignty-as-a-given%2F

In fact, Westminster sovereignty actually ensures that such a parliament can – and as we have seen, will – overturn any initiative, rescind any law and refuse any request we make without even having to give a reason.

For example, tax and regulatory plans from Holyrood would still have to be approved elsewhere in case they affect others – such as England – but we would have no reciprocal say.

Granting legal personality to Scotland to allow international agreements on devolved areas would be negated if it cut across Westminster policies whilst rejoining the EU and removing nuclear weapons from our soil would remain as impossible as they are today.

That is why we must never accept that Westminster sovereignty is a given in the governance of Scotland.

To become independent, we must challenge it whenever we suffer it, and that fight should always be taken directly and vigorously to where it still holds sway – Westminster itself.

Elections Independence Westminster Yes
Previous ArticlePriorities for the Scottish Budget
Next Article Pension Credit Extra Payment Deadline
Lucie

I am working as a Constituency Assistant for Graeme. I joined the team after doing a master's degree at the University of Glasgow.

Related Posts

Spending Review presents challenges

12th June 2025

Call for National Mission on Living Standards

23rd May 2025

Graeme’s Column

13th May 2025
latest news

Securing Grangemouth’s Just Transition

More Support for Care-Experienced Youth

Scottish Languages Bill Passed

Scrapping 2-Child Limit to Fight Child Poverty

About
About

Graeme Dey is the the Member of the Scottish Parliament for Angus South Constituency.

Having worked for The Courier newspaper for 26 years, Graeme was elected to Holyrood in 2011.

In March 2023, Graeme was chosen by First Minister Humza Yousaf to be Minister for Higher and Further Education; and Minister for Veterans.

Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube
Latest Posts

Securing Grangemouth’s Just Transition

More Support for Care-Experienced Youth

Scottish Languages Bill Passed

Scrapping 2-Child Limit to Fight Child Poverty

Flickr Photos
Transport Police
RM Condor Parliament 2
D&A College (Apprenticeship Week) 6
Deaf Hub 3
DofE3
Humza and Graeme close up pro
Humza Graeme Sign
Independence Convention
July7 Surgery 2]
CWA Parl 3
20230712_104835
20230712_110433
Banking Hub 1
SSERC
Ayrshire College
Poverty Alliance
© 2025 Graeme Dey MSP. No parliamentary funds have been used to create and maintain this website. Promoted by G. Dey, 282 High St, DD11 1JF.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.